The Reef Top The Reef Top The Reef Top The Reef Top The Reef Top The Reef Top
  • The Reef Top
  • We Are On Top
  • The Reef Top
  • We Are Fresh
We pursue perfection, so that each dish comes out on Top.


About Us
So here’s how the Reef Top came about …. John and Patti Broshar, owners of the Pelican’s Reef, decided to take over the space located directly above the restaurant back in 2013. The original concept was to create space that would allow for customers to have a place to grab a drink, maybe catch a sporting event on TV while they waited for their table downstairs. As construction continued, they decided to take the concept a little bit further by putting in a separate kitchen, a full bar and a restaurant with a completely different look and vibe.

The Reef Top was born and opened its doors in May 2014! The Reef Top menu is somewhat different than the Pelican’s Reef, however the offerings, including the nightly specials, are equally unique and inspiring. So whether you’re dining “up or down”, you’re in for a great treat!
Menu
View Specials

Open Printable Menu



APPETIZERS

Wings (10)
$11.99
Cajun/Mild/Hot/Teriyaki/BBQ

Mozzarella Sticks (8)
$6.99

Chicken Fingers (4)
$7.99

Fat Tire Beer Cheese & Pretzels
$8.99

Onion Rings
$5.99



ISLAND FAVORITES

Calamari (voted Best in Cincinnati)
$11.99
Served with a homemade marinara or sweet chili sauce

Fried Oysters (8)
$14.99
Served with jalapeno tartar sauce

Coconut Shrimp (5)
$9.99
Served with a apricot & key lime horseradish dipping sauce

Cajun Popcorn Shrimp
$9.99
Served with cocktail sauce

Ahi Tuna
$12.00
Topped with wasabi soy vinaigrette, greens & crispy wontons

Pan Sautéed Crab Cake (2)
$14.99
Served with chipotle tartar sauce

Bruschetta
$12.00
With Steak or Shrimp, tomato basil salsa, mozzarella

Peel & Eat Shrimp
The best tasting steamed prawns served hot or cold

$11.50
½ lb.

$20.50
1 lb.



PO ‘BOY SANDWICHES

Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, chipotle tartar sauce & one side item
Fried Shrimp
$14.99

Fried Oysters
$15.99



WRAPS

Mahi or Grouper
$14.99
Served with lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese, mayo (on the side) w/ 1 side item

Chicken
$11.99
Served with lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese, mayo (on the side) w/ 1 side item



STEAK

Served with 2 side item.
New York Strip 12 oz.
$24.99
Served with two side items



BASKETS

Served with two side items.
Fried Oyster Basket
$16.99

Fried Shrimp Basket
$14.99

Fried Coconut Shrimp Basket
$14.99

Fried Cod Basket
$14.99
Hand Breaded Icelandic cod

Combo Basket
$16.99
Select two seafood items



GRILLED & BROILED FISH PLATTERS

Served with two side items.
Grilled Tuna
$19.99

Grilled Mahi Mahi
$18.99

Grilled Salmon
$18.99
Available w/ Bourbon Glaze

Halibut
$19.99

Grilled Walleye
$21.99



SALAD - CAESAR, SOUTHWESTERN & SIGNATURE – served with garlic bread

Caesar
$7.99
Romaine lettuce with parmesan cheese, croutons & our own Caesar dressing

Southwestern
$7.99
Mixed greens with roasted red peppers, onions, roasted corn, black beans, tomatoes, cheddar cheese, tortilla strips, and chipotle ranch dressing

Signature
$7.99
Mixed greens, arugula, grape tomatoes, chopped egg, goat cheese, candied walnuts, red onion, dried craisins, croutons & Fuji apple vinaigrette

w/ Grilled Chicken
$12.99

w/ Grilled Grouper
$14.99

w/ Grilled Tuna
$16.99

w/ Grilled Mahi Mahi
$14.99

w/ Grilled Salmon
$16.99

w/ Grilled Scallops
$17.99

w/ Grilled Shrimp
$13.99

w/ Calimari
$13.99



TACOS

Fish Tacos
$14.99
Featuring the fish of the day; served with lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese & Jamaican relish; and one side item

Island Tacos
$14.99
Blackened Mahi Mahi, grilled shrimp or chicken with pepper jack cheese, Caribbean slaw and chipotle sour cream and one side item



REEF TOP SANDWICHES

Served on a bun or rye bread with lettuce, tomato, onion & tartar sauce. Add Cajun to any sandwich. Add American, provolone, cheddar or pepper jack cheese to any sandwich for 1.00. Served with one side item.
Mesquite Grilled Grouper Sandwich
$14.99

Grilled Mahi Mahi
$14.99

Grilled Tuna
$15.99

Grilled Alaskan Halibut
$17.99

Beer Battered Cod
$11.99

Beer Battered Lake Erie Perch
$11.99

Grilled Mahi Club
$15.99
w/ Provolone Cheese & Bacon

Cajun Grilled Grouper Sandwich
$15.50
w/ Provolone Cheese, Chipotle Pepper Tartar Sauce & Serveed on Rye Bread

Pulled Pork Sandwich
$9.99
w/ Cole Slaw

Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$11.99
w/ Mayo

Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich
$12.99
w/ Mayo & Bacon

Reef Top Burger
$10.99
w/ Mayo (Bacon add $1.00)

Reef Top Cheese Burger
$10.99
w/ Mayo (Bacon add $1.00)



SIDE ITEMS

Garlic Bread
Sweet Potato Fries
French Fries
Cole Slaw
Dirty Rice
Caesar Salad
Tossed Salad




KIDS MENU

Drink Included – Choice of Fries/Sweet Potato Fries/Tossed Salad/Caesar
Chicken Fingers
$5.99

Cheeseburger
$5.99

Shrimp Basket
$5.99

Kids Pasta with Marinara Sauce
$5.99
Parmesan Cheese & Garlic Bread



SALAD DRESSINGS

Ranch
Italian
Blue Cheese
Balsamic Vinaigrette
Honey Mustard
Thousand Island
French
Fat Free Ranch


Drinks
Imports/Microbrews
Amstel Light
Heineken
Corona
Corona
Crabbies
Ginger Beer
Guinness
Jackie O's
Firefly Amber
Mystic Mama IPA
Pacifico
Red Stripe
Sam Adams
Yuenling Lager
Beer Domestic
Budweiser
Bud Light
Bud Select
Coors Light
Michelob Ultra
Miller Lite
O'Douls
White Wine
Hogue Riesling, Columbia Valley, Washington
Bright Flavors of Peach and Apricot with a Touch of Sweetness.
Luna Pinot Grigio, California
Crisp, Clean Flavors of Citrus, Lemon/Lime with a Fresh Finish.
Souverain Chardonnay, North Coast
Classic Flavors of Apple, Pear with Hints of Toasted Oak and Vanilla.
Lincourt 'Steel' Chardonnay, Santa Rita Hills
An Un-Oaked Version with Clean Flavors of Tropical Fruit and Bright Acidity.
Red Wine
Garnet Pinot Noir, Monterey
Bright, Crisp Flavors of Cherry and Blackberry with Hints of Vanilla and Spice.
Etude 'Lyric' Pinot Noir, Santa Barbara
Ripe Flavors of Bing Cherry and Strawberry with a Long, Velvety Finish.
19 Crimes Red Blen, Australia
Blend of Shiraz Greache and Cabernet Sauvignon Flavors of Blueberry and Plum with Hints of Vanilla. Extremely Smooth.
Irony Merlot, Napa Valley
Flavors of Plum and Blackberry with Hints of Mocha and a Smooth Finish.
Layer Cake Malbec, Mendoza Argentina
Big Bold Flavors of Blackberry and Dark Cocoa with a Silky, Juicy Finish.
Sebastiani Cabernet Sauvignon, Sonoma
Vibrant Fruit Flavors of Plum, Blackberry and Cherry with a Touch of Toasted Oak.